Melbourne man denied A$30,000 refund after purchasing 'fake' shoes from teen

Melbourne man denied A$30,000 refund after purchasing 'fake' shoes from teen

By fijivillage
Sunday 28/01/2024
Dior and Nike collaborated in 2020 to release the limited-edition sneakers

A Melbourne man who spent nearly 30,000 Australian dollars (£16,100) on shoes he now believes to be fake has had his case thrown out by a tribunal.

He was seeking a refund for seven pairs of sneakers, some of them ultra-rare shoes produced jointly by sportswear and fashion giants Nike and Dior.

But state legal authorities found he had knowingly bought the trainers from a boy who was only 17 at the time.

That meant he could not sign contracts and was not liable for refunds.

In October last year, the man, an estate agent, took the 17-year-old student and his father to the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Vcat) to ask for a refund on the seven pairs of shoes.

Four of the pairs were limited-edition shoes from a collaboration between Nike and Dior. Only 4,700 high-tops and 8,500 low-tops of the Dior x Nike Air Jordan 1 sneakers were available for purchase via a raffle system.

The man paid sums ranging from A$3,800 (£2,040) to A$10,000 (£5,370) for each pair of Nike Air Jordan 1 Dior sneakers, as well as A$2,690 (£1,445) for three pairs of Nike Air Jordan 1 sneakers in various colours.

After receiving the shoes, the man told the Vcat that he noticed "defects" and contacted the seller for a refund - but did not receive a reply and went on to contact the teen's father.


He claims the boy's father accompanied him to local authenticators, who immediately recognised the teen as a "fraudster and scam artist" by name. The teen and his father disputed that the shoes were "unauthentic" and that the store used to check the sneakers was authorised to authenticate them.

The seller's father also told the tribunal that he only became involved in the situation to "protect the safety of his family" after his son was chased through a shopping centre.

Dismissing the claim in December, Vcat member Katherine Metcalf said that the father's involvement was not enough to suggest that he was responsible for the refund, and that the agreement was between the man and the student only.

But as the seller was underage when the shoes were sold, he was not legally able to enter into a contract or liable to make any refunds under Victorian state law.

"Had the agreement been entered into when [the seller] was 18 years old the result might have been different," Ms Metcalf wrote in her reasons for the dismissal.

"Whilst the law generally protects minors from the consequences of their own actions, it could be argued that in the present circumstances it is not the minor who needs protection, but rather the people with whom he chose to do business."

Source: Fashion

Tuwai seeks parents’ blessings to help him win 3rd Olympic gold
It was an emotional farewell for Fiji 7s legend and two-time Olympics gold-medallist Jerry Tuwai and his family when the 35-year-old left our shores w...
4 hours ago
Youth admitted at the Vunisea Hospital after involvement in an alleged break-in
A youth of Vunisea in Kadavu is currently admitted at the Vunisea Hospital after he was assaulted when he allegedly broke into a home in ...
4 hours ago

WAF operations team finds signs of sabotage
The water disruption experienced within the Colo-i-Suva Village has been resolved as the issue was caused by a failing pumping system at the Forestry ...
4 hours ago

Masi and Sauturaga’s family hyped to watch the two players play at the Olympics
Team Fiji Men’s Rugby 7s players Iosefo Masi and Filipe Sauturaga's family are all hyped up to watch the two players take the field in the Paris ...
4 hours ago

4 men remanded for aggravated robbery in Lautoka
Four men have been remanded by the Lautoka Magistrates Court for their alleged involvement in an aggravated robbery case in Lautoka. Police say it ...
5 hours ago

Serua Village youths unite for mangrove restoration to protect island from climate threats
The youths of Serua Village in Serua are now working together for the Serua mangrove rehabilitation to fight against rising sea levels and climate ...
6 hours ago

fijivillage Straight Talk with Vijay Narayan
Latest Videos

Stay tuned for the latest news on our radio stations

CFL radio frequencies
Time to speak out about human trafficking in Fiji
Human trafficking has a long history in Fiji, dating back over 150 years to the era of indentured labour and blackbirding, when many were forcibly ...
1 day ago

Naca Cawanibuka on fijivillage Straight Talk With Vijay Narayan
Accomplished Strength and Conditioning Coach for the Olympics gold medal winning teams in Rio and Tokyo, Naca Cawanibuka on fijivillage Straight Talk ...
1 day ago

Acting Director of Substance Abuse Advisory Council on fijivillage Straight Talk With Vijay Narayan
Acting Director of the National Substance Abuse Advisory Council, Josua Naisele on fijivillage Straight Talk With Vijay Narayan
2 days ago