DPPs Office remains concerned about the conduct of the Magistrate in Bainimarama and Qiliho’s case
Magistrate Puamau denies application saying it does not meet the threshold for actual or apparent bias

DPPs Office remains concerned about the conduct of the Magistrate in Bainimarama and Qiliho’s case

Magistrate Puamau denies application saying it does not meet the threshold for actual or apparent bias

By Vijay Narayan , Rashika Kumar
Monday 13/03/2023

The Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions remains concerned about the conduct of the Magistrate throughout the hearing in the case of former Prime Minister, Voreqe Bainimarama and suspended Police Commissioner, Sitiveni Qiliho.

DPP lawyer, Jayneeta Prasad had made an application for Magistrate Seini Puamau to recuse herself from the Bainimarama-Qiliho case on the grounds of apparent bias however it was denied.

Bainimarama and Qiliho pleaded not guilty to a count each of abuse of office and have been granted bail.

The charges relate to a complaint laid with the police by the University of the South Pacific in July 2020 in relation to the activities of former staff members of the university.

Prasad had requested to make the application in closed chambers however it was denied by the Magistrate.

The DPP lawyer says the alleged bias stems from comments made in the morning during the hearing on bail where Magistrate Puamau had said "they may come back into power again".

While responding to the application on Friday, Bainimarama and Qiliho’s lawyer, Devanesh Sharma said they oppose the application as there has to be actual or apparent bias that goes to the heart of the fact.

He says the comments are made based on facts.

Sharma adds it is speculation what position Bainimarama may have in the future.

Magistrate Puamau denied the application stating that it does not meet the threshold for actual or apparent bias.

She says she can cite historical figures who came back into power such as Winston Churchill or Prime Minister Sitiveni Rabuka.

She further says that is how politics works and that the former Prime Minister, if interested, may stand again and Qiliho is only suspended.

The Magistrate says she did not intend to treat them differently.

The Office of the DPP says a recusal application is made whenever there is actual bias shown by a judge or magistrate or where there is an apprehended risk of bias.

The DPPs Office says in this case, the Magistrate had made statements in open court that could be perceived as bias against the State.

As a result of those comments, the State made an application for the Magistrate to recuse herself.



Latest Videos

Stay tuned for the latest news on our radio stations

CFL radio frequencies
IN DEPTH
Girmit Celebrations 2023
The Girmit story isn’t a story confined to one community in Fiji, it is a story that belongs to all of us. This was highlighted by the National ...
10 days ago

Fiscal Review Commitee members, Richard Naidu and Vani Catanasiga appear on fijivillage Straight Talk with Vijay Narayan
Fiscal Review Committee chair, Richard Naidu and senior member, Vani Catanasiga appeared on fijivillage Straight Talk with Vijay Narayan to discuss ...
11 days ago

Prof. Prasad appears on fijivillage Straight Talk With Vijay Narayan
Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Finance Professor Biman Prasad appeared on fijivillage Straight Talk with Vijay Narayan
13 days ago
FEATURE NEWS
Technical education environment is a disaster – Prof. Prasad
Acting Prime Minister and Minister for Finance Professor Biman Prasad says the technical education environment is a disaster in this country and the g...
9 hours ago
LATEST NEWS
Continue to work hand in hand to serve the needs of every Fijian - Dr Lalabalavu
Let us continue to work hand in hand, leveraging our expertise, resources, and innovation to create a healthcare system that serves the needs of ...
9 hours ago

More people arrested for illicit drugs over the last 48 hours
Three men were arrested and charged in Nadi earlier this week for unlawful possession of illicit drugs, while more arrests were made in the last 48 ...
9 hours ago

Jeremy Renner Breaks Silence On MCU Future 5 Months After Terrifying Accident
After months of working to recover from his terrifying accident, Jeremy Renner has an optimistic update about his Marvel Cinematic Universe ...
14 hours ago

Business Assistance Fiji and Business Link Pacific focus on grassroots entrepreneur - Chand
The General Manager of Business Assistance Fiji and Business Link Pacific Ramesh Chand says phase two of the Business Link Pacific business support ...
14 hours ago

So much wisdom, knowledge and experience in our communities in terms of sharing ideas – Prof Prasad
There is so much wisdom, knowledge and experience that our people, our institution and our communities can share in terms of ideas. This was ...
16 hours ago

TOP