DPPs Office remains concerned about the conduct of the Magistrate in Bainimarama and Qiliho’s case
Magistrate Puamau denies application saying it does not meet the threshold for actual or apparent bias

DPPs Office remains concerned about the conduct of the Magistrate in Bainimarama and Qiliho’s case

Magistrate Puamau denies application saying it does not meet the threshold for actual or apparent bias

By Vijay Narayan , Rashika Kumar
Monday 13/03/2023

The Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions remains concerned about the conduct of the Magistrate throughout the hearing in the case of former Prime Minister, Voreqe Bainimarama and suspended Police Commissioner, Sitiveni Qiliho.

DPP lawyer, Jayneeta Prasad had made an application for Magistrate Seini Puamau to recuse herself from the Bainimarama-Qiliho case on the grounds of apparent bias however it was denied.

Bainimarama and Qiliho pleaded not guilty to a count each of abuse of office and have been granted bail.

The charges relate to a complaint laid with the police by the University of the South Pacific in July 2020 in relation to the activities of former staff members of the university.

Prasad had requested to make the application in closed chambers however it was denied by the Magistrate.

The DPP lawyer says the alleged bias stems from comments made in the morning during the hearing on bail where Magistrate Puamau had said "they may come back into power again".

While responding to the application on Friday, Bainimarama and Qiliho’s lawyer, Devanesh Sharma said they oppose the application as there has to be actual or apparent bias that goes to the heart of the fact.

He says the comments are made based on facts.

Sharma adds it is speculation what position Bainimarama may have in the future.

Magistrate Puamau denied the application stating that it does not meet the threshold for actual or apparent bias.

She says she can cite historical figures who came back into power such as Winston Churchill or Prime Minister Sitiveni Rabuka.

She further says that is how politics works and that the former Prime Minister, if interested, may stand again and Qiliho is only suspended.

The Magistrate says she did not intend to treat them differently.

The Office of the DPP says a recusal application is made whenever there is actual bias shown by a judge or magistrate or where there is an apprehended risk of bias.

The DPPs Office says in this case, the Magistrate had made statements in open court that could be perceived as bias against the State.

As a result of those comments, the State made an application for the Magistrate to recuse herself.




fijivillage Straight Talk with Vijay Narayan
Latest Videos

Stay tuned for the latest news on our radio stations

CFL radio frequencies
FEATURE NEWS
I did tell Ben, I’m a gold man - Mazey
Fiji Rugby Football Union Trust Board Interim Chair, Peter Mazey has made it clear that there were no threats made to Fiji Airways Men’s National 7s...
8 hours ago
LATEST NEWS
4% increase in price of normal flour from today
People will need to pay more when purchasing normal flour as the price will increase by 4 percent from today. This has been determined by the ...
7 hours ago

Underwood starts her business with paper craft during COVID-19
It was a great day for the new entrepreneurs, who are part of the Academy for Women Entrepreneurs Program, to showcase their art and craft and also ...
7 hours ago

SVC head girl and Dux Raina Kumar encourages students to follow their dreams
Raina Saanvi Kumar who is the head girl of Swami Vivekananda College in Nadi is encouraging all students to follow their dreams, work hard to achieve ...
8 hours ago

Include NCDs and healthy living in PE classes in school – Dr Qereqeretabua and Dr Ahmed
The General Surgeon at the CWM Hospital, Doctor Timoci Qereqeretabua and the Principal Medical Officer at the National Diabetes Centre, Doctor Momtaz ...
8 hours ago

Teachers of Nasinu Gospel Primary claim they have been asked to leave the school premises by the Head Teacher
21 teachers of Nasinu Gospel Primary School are calling on the Minister for Education to respond to their concerns after they were asked to leave the ...
8 hours ago
IN DEPTH
PM’s motion passed to reduce overseas travel allowances for the PM, Ministers, Assistant Ministers, Leader of Opposition and MPs
Parliament has passed the Prime Minister’s motion to reduce the rates payable for overseas travelling allowances for the Prime Minister, Cabinet ...
16 days ago

CEO of the Fijian Competition and Consumer Commission, Joel Abraham appears on fijivillage Straight Talk With Vijay Narayan
CEO of the Fijian Competition and Consumer Commission, Joel Abraham appears on fijivillage Straight Talk With Vijay ...
22 days ago

HIV infections in Fiji increased 260% since 2010, making Fiji the second fastest-growing epidemic in the Asia Pacific region
Speaker of Parliament and UNAIDS Goodwill Ambassador for the Pacific Region, Ratu Epeli Nailatikau says according to the Global AIDS Monitoring Report, Fiji is in the top 5 countries of rising new HIV infections in the Asia Pacific region amongst the 15 t
27 days ago

TOP