Sharvada Sharma’s dismissal as SG in breach of the clear requirements of the Constitution – Law Society
Clarke says the SG can only be removed on the advice of a tribunal appointed by the President after an enquiry

Sharvada Sharma’s dismissal as SG in breach of the clear requirements of the Constitution – Law Society

Clarke says the SG can only be removed on the advice of a tribunal appointed by the President after an enquiry

By Vijay Narayan
Friday 12/11/2021
Law Society President, Wylie Clarke.

The Fiji Law Society is seriously concerned about Sharvada Sharma’s dismissal as Solicitor General in breach of the clear requirements of the 2013 Constitution and the Judicial Services Commission’s explicit confirmation that a tribunal would be appointed to investigate the allegations of misbehaviour made against him.

Law Society President, Wylie Clarke says the termination of Sharma’s appointment without due process being afforded to him is a grave assault on the rule of law and threatens the independence of critical constitutional offices.

Clarke says they are also concerned that the removal may be unlawful.

The Law Society President says the office of Solicitor General, like that of judges and magistrates and the Director of Public Prosecutions, is protected under the Constitution.

Clarke says this protection is essential to maintain the independence of those offices, free of political and other interference and also means that there is a very strict and clear process by which such a removal can be done.

He says the Constitution states that the Solicitor General can only be removed for very limited and serious reasons on the advice of a tribunal appointed by the President: (i) an inability to perform the functions of the office due, for example, to serious illness; or (ii) misbehaviour.

Clarke says the Solicitor General cannot be removed in any other way.

He says the tribunal is made up of current and former judges to ensure impartiality and independence and is charged with enquiring into the allegations.

The Law Society President adds that enquiry would involve obtaining statements from the complainant and witnesses, gathering evidence and, most importantly, affording Sharvada Sharma the right to respond and answer the allegation(s).

Clarke says at the conclusion of that enquiry, the tribunal would furnish the President with a report and provide its advice on whether Sharma should be removed or not.

He says the Judicial Services Commission has no power to render such advice.

Clarke says as far as they are aware, no such tribunal was appointed, no such enquiry conducted and no such advice tendered to the President.

He says an allegation of misbehaviour is very serious because it involves matters such as corruption, unlawful acts and abuse of office.

The Law Society President says misbehaviour does not include decisions, opinions or acts that are unpopular or not liked (or agreed to) by others.

He says the gravity of such an allegation against the holder of a constitutional office demands transparency and accountability, and the community has a right to know.

Clarke says it is for this reason that the Constitution requires that any report prepared by the tribunal must be made public.

He says the rule of law has been severely undermined by the manner in which Sharma has been removed because it sets a very dangerous precedent that could be used just as easily against judges and the Director of Public Prosecutions.

No time frame given for the salvage operations of RFNS Puamau
No timeline has been given on how long the salvage operations for the RFNS Puamau will take as the Fiji Navy has started the de-fuelling process in Fu...
11 hours ago
Chance for a reset
As Prime Minister Sitiveni Rabuka reflects on his position post the extraordinary events of the last two weeks his options may appear intoxicating, ...
11 hours ago

Committee silent on 7-year tax holiday to Fiji Water – Chaudhry
Fiji Labour Party leader, Mahendra Chaudhry says it is surprising that the 2023 Fiscal Review Committee which has submitted a range of taxation ...
11 hours ago

Fiscal Review Committee wants departure tax to be increased
The Fiscal Review Committee is recommending a staggered implementation of the departure tax to $170 from 1st April 2025 and $200 from 1st April 2026 ...
11 hours ago

Govt not considering 30% pay increase for teachers – Prof. Prasad
A 30 percent increase is not something the government is considering for teachers. Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Finance, Professor Biman ...
15 hours ago

Excitement builds up as Hibiscus Festival coming back after 5 years
Excitement is in the air as Suva braces to hold the mother of all festivals, the Miss Hibiscus Festival which will be held after a lapse of 5 ...
16 hours ago

fijivillage Straight Talk with Vijay Narayan
Latest Videos

Stay tuned for the latest news on our radio stations

CFL radio frequencies
Crisis within FijiFirst relating to the termination of 17 MPs who voted for salary increases
A crisis has erupted within the FijiFirst party relating to the termination of 17 members of parliament who supported the government's motion to ...
5 days ago

Pre-Budget 2024-2025
Pre Budget 2024-2025 budget recommendations and an insight of what people on the ground wish to see in the National Budget
7 days ago

Sayed-Khaiyum case on alleged payment of Saneem's taxes without proper approval
It is alleged that between the 30th of June, 2022 and the 12th of July, 2022 in Suva, whilst being employed in the civil service as the Acting Prime ...
8 days ago