Puma and Nike's plans to phase out kangaroo leather misguided, industry stakeholders say

Puma and Nike's plans to phase out kangaroo leather misguided, industry stakeholders say

By abc.net.au
Tuesday 21/03/2023
Puma and Nike have said they will phase out using kangaroo leather in their shoes.(Supplied: Darren Gall)

An Indigenous kangaroo shooter says a decision by Nike and Puma to no longer use kangaroo leather in their soccer shoes is going to have unintended consequences.

The sportswear giants have over the past two weeks indicated that they would stop using kangaroo leather (or K-leather), replacing it with their own synthetic materials — a move that will have serious effects for tanneries and roo harvesters.

The owners of an Adelaide-based tannery have already said they would be shutting its doors, while those from a 130-year-old tannery in Queensland said it could be badly affected.

Lindsay Packer operates Brisbane-based Packer Leather.

"It's a large part of what we do, about 30 per cent," he said.

K-leather is known to be lighter and more durable than other animal hides, but animal welfare advocates say the industry is inhumane because it kills joeys or leaves them to starve after their mother has been shot.

Opponents misguided, harvester says

Garry Trindall is an Aboriginal man and harvests wild kangaroos for a meat and hide processor in Walgett, in northern NSW.

He has been harvesting them for more than 50 years.

Mr Trindall said concerns for joeys were misguided because most professional shooters only shot larger kangaroos.

"We try to cull what needs to be culled, that's the older and bigger kangaroos," he said.

"Nine times out of 10, if we shoot those, they have joeys that are big enough to survive by themselves."

Kangaroo population unnatural

He said the current high number of kangaroos across the land was unnatural.

"When Captain Cook came here, there were hardly any kangaroos because they could only live along the river," Mr Trindall said.

"But when the white man settled, the farming and the water that they used for it allowed the kangaroos to multiply by the millions."

With the kangaroo populations so high that they caused damage to crops, Mr Trindall said farmers were going to shoot them anyway, and it would not necessarily be humane.

"As an Aboriginal person, we know our country. We know our land," he said.

"If you stop the professional shooters and the Aboriginal people from harvesting, you'll get people shooting kangaroos willy nilly."

While animal welfare advocates wanted to see an end to kangaroos being shot and killed for leather, Mr Trindall said the move by Puma and Nike could have the opposite effect.

"If prices for the carcasses go down because there's less demand for the leather, then more kangaroos will have to be killed to keep up the same income," he said.

Comparison drawn with fisheries

Opponents argue that once a profit motive is introduced for the killing of native animals, the populations are liable to collapse no matter how many regulations are in place.

Filmmaker Mick McIntyre runs the group Kangaroos Alive, which has campaigned to stop the use of kangaroo leather.

"You only have to look at whaling, you only have to look at ivory, you only have to look at fisheries," McIntrye said.

"Fisheries are one of the most regulated industry in the world and every single fishery stock is collapsing.

"Kangaroos are no different."

A better alternative

But Kangaroo Industries Association of Australia president Ray Borda said the kangaroo industry was a more sustainable alternative to cattle and sheep.

He said kangaroos produced one third of the carbon footprint because they emitted less methane, required less water, put less pressure on grazing lands, and used no energy to capture or contain the animals.

"All commercial industry kangaroo leather is a by-product of the meat industry which would otherwise end up in landfill," Mr Borda said.

"The kangaroo industry is more eco-friendly because of its longevity and biodegradability."

But opponents of the industry were not convinced.

"Once you make wildlife a commodity, the wildlife lose," McIntyre said.

Drua's hopes for playoff spot still alive after 28-19 win over Reds
The Swire Shipping Fijian Drua's hopes of making the playoffs of the Shop N Save Super Rugby Pacific competition are still alive after defeating the R...
4 hours ago
RFNS Puamau to assist Fiji’s ability to protect its waters - Rabuka
While commissioning the new naval vessel RFNS Puamau, Prime Minister Sitiveni Rabuka says the vessel vessel has arrived at a critical time to assist ...
2 hours ago

Sanatan Dharm Pratinidhi Sabha seeks to boost youth involvement and community engagement through temple consultations
To get more people engaged in the running of their respective temples and increasing participation in religious festivities, the Sanatan Dharm ...
2 hours ago

Fiji Museum unveils third gallery featuring unique artifacts
Families gathered in numbers to celebrate International Museum Day 2024 as the Fiji Museum opened its third gallery today. A few of the artifacts ...
2 hours ago

Grammarians blessed to be part of the 60th+4 Diamond Jubilee celebrations
During the official opening of the Suva Grammar School’s 60th+4 Diamond Jubilee celebrations, many Grammarians were seen reminiscing about their ...
3 hours ago

FELT Framework promotes minimum wage for local tradesmen and women
The Framework on Engaging Local Tradesmen/Women is promoting minimum wage standards, indicating a new era of fair compensation and empowerment for ...
3 hours ago

fijivillage Straight Talk with Vijay Narayan
Latest Videos

Stay tuned for the latest news on our radio stations

CFL radio frequencies
Ministry of Home Affairs Talanoa Session on Illicit Drugs and Substance Use Disorders in Fiji
The pervasive threat of illicit drugs has emerged as a pressing concern, rapidly infiltrating and destabilizing our society therefore the Republic of ...
1 day ago

Bainimarama and Qiliho hearing in dismissal of 2 police officers case
Acting Director of Public Prosecutions John Rabuku says he wants the hearing of former Prime Minister Voreqe Bainimarama and suspended Police ...
1 day ago