Court rules UK government's plan to send asylum seekers to Rwanda is illegal

Court rules UK government's plan to send asylum seekers to Rwanda is illegal

Thursday 16/11/2023
The court ruling will come as a blow to Rishi Sunak, but be celebrated among human rights groups.(Reuters: John Sibley)

Britain's Supreme Court has ruled that the government's scheme to send asylum seekers to Rwanda is unlawful, dealing a crushing blow to Prime Minister Rishi Sunak before an election expected next year.

Under the plan, Britain intended to send tens of thousands of asylum seekers who arrived on its shores without permission to the East African country in a bid to deter migrants crossing the Channel from Europe in small boats.

But the top court on Wednesday unanimously rejected the government's appeal against an earlier ruling that migrants could not be sent to Rwanda because it could not be considered a safe third country.

President Robert Reed said the five judges involved agreed there were "substantial grounds for believing that asylum seekers sent to Rwanda would be at real risk of refoulement", meaning being sent back to their country of origin where they could be at risk of ill-treatment.

The Rwanda scheme was the central plank of Mr Sunak's immigration policy as he prepares to face an election next year, amid concern among some voters about the numbers of asylum seekers arriving in small boats.

Mr Sunak, whose Conservatives are trailing by about 20 points in opinion polls, had made a promise to "stop the boats", one of the five key pledges of his premiership.

This year more than 27,000 people have arrived on the southern English coast without permission, after a record 45,755 were detected in 2022.

Mr Sunak said the government had been planning for all eventualities and would do whatever it took to stop illegal migration.

After the decision was handed down, Mr Sunak released a statement saying: "We have seen today's judgement and will now consider next steps."

"This was not the outcome we wanted, but we have spent the last few months planning for all eventualities and we remain completely committed to stopping the boats."

The ruling had taken on even greater political significance in recent days after Mr Sunak sacked Home Secretary Suella Braverman, a popular figure on his party's right-wing, whose remit included dealing with immigration.

She launched a scathing attack on Mr Sunak on Tuesday, saying he had broken promises on tackling immigration and betrayed the British people.

Critics, ranging from opposition politicians, as well as some in his own party, to church leaders and the United Nations refugee agency, had argued the policy was flawed, immoral and simply would not work.

"The Supreme Court's judgement is a victory for humanity," Steve Smith, chief executive of refugee charity Care4Calais, said. "This grubby, cash-for-people deal was always cruel and immoral but, most importantly, it is unlawful."

The Rwanda policy was originally drawn up by former prime minister Boris Johnson in an initial 140 million-pound ($180 million) deal.

Whilst the court said it was now unlawful, Judge Reed left open the chance the scheme could be resurrected, saying "the changes needed to eliminate the risk of refoulement may be delivered in the future, but they have not been shown to be in place now".

With many politicians in Mr Sunak's party saying Britain should consider leaving the European Convention on Human Rights over the issue, the judge said their decision was based on a number of laws and treaties, and not the convention alone.

After the ruling, a Rwandan government spokesperson said it took issue with the conclusion that Rwanda was not a safe third country.

By Reuters

Original article link:

Tuwai seeks parents’ blessings to help him win 3rd Olympic gold
It was an emotional farewell for Fiji 7s legend and two-time Olympics gold-medallist Jerry Tuwai and his family when the 35-year-old left our shores w...
4 hours ago
Youth admitted at the Vunisea Hospital after involvement in an alleged break-in
A youth of Vunisea in Kadavu is currently admitted at the Vunisea Hospital after he was assaulted when he allegedly broke into a home in ...
4 hours ago

WAF operations team finds signs of sabotage
The water disruption experienced within the Colo-i-Suva Village has been resolved as the issue was caused by a failing pumping system at the Forestry ...
4 hours ago

Masi and Sauturaga’s family hyped to watch the two players play at the Olympics
Team Fiji Men’s Rugby 7s players Iosefo Masi and Filipe Sauturaga's family are all hyped up to watch the two players take the field in the Paris ...
4 hours ago

4 men remanded for aggravated robbery in Lautoka
Four men have been remanded by the Lautoka Magistrates Court for their alleged involvement in an aggravated robbery case in Lautoka. Police say it ...
5 hours ago

Serua Village youths unite for mangrove restoration to protect island from climate threats
The youths of Serua Village in Serua are now working together for the Serua mangrove rehabilitation to fight against rising sea levels and climate ...
6 hours ago

fijivillage Straight Talk with Vijay Narayan
Latest Videos

Stay tuned for the latest news on our radio stations

CFL radio frequencies
Time to speak out about human trafficking in Fiji
Human trafficking has a long history in Fiji, dating back over 150 years to the era of indentured labour and blackbirding, when many were forcibly ...
1 day ago

Naca Cawanibuka on fijivillage Straight Talk With Vijay Narayan
Accomplished Strength and Conditioning Coach for the Olympics gold medal winning teams in Rio and Tokyo, Naca Cawanibuka on fijivillage Straight Talk ...
1 day ago

Acting Director of Substance Abuse Advisory Council on fijivillage Straight Talk With Vijay Narayan
Acting Director of the National Substance Abuse Advisory Council, Josua Naisele on fijivillage Straight Talk With Vijay Narayan
2 days ago