High Court Judge Justice Paul Madigan has dismissed Jagath Karunaratne’s application for stay on the grounds of abuse of charge and has also dismissed his application for constitutional redress by staying proceedings.
Karunaratne is charged with Mosese Bulitavu for allegedly writing seditious comments at various places within Suva in 2011 and their case is before the Suva Magistrates court.
Karunaratne’s lawyer, Aman Ravindra Singh had submitted to the High Court that although there was a functioning government in Fiji from 2009 to 2013 and although it was the government of the day accepted as legitimate by all branches of society, it was not established by law.
He submitted that the 1997 constitution having been abrogated and the 2013 constitution not then enacted, the interim government was not established by law and as a result no person could be said to be acting seditiously to a government established by law.
Justice Madigan says before considering whether a stay of proceedings and or relief by way of constitutional redress is appropriate, it must be first stated that the substantive claim would appear to be misconceived.
He says apart from seeming to rely on the false premise that only a government being in place under an extant constitution can be lawful, Singh also appears to be of the view that “established by law” means a law or legislation that legitimizes the particular government in place, a misconception that would preclude the law of prescription, acquiescence or even the appointment of a government by a Head of State who is legally in office.
Justice Madigan says to bring such an application before the High Court is in itself an abuse of process. He says while the High Court does not have supervisory powers over proceedings in a lower court it will not intervene in proceedings already in train below.
He says the accused has the right to challenge the charge in a submission of no case at the end of the prosecution case and should he not succeed in such an application then he has the right to appeal in accordance with the appellate rules and regulations.